Thursday, May 2, 2013



It is more than two weeks now since a platoon of the PLA of China moved about 19 kms into Indian-claimed territory in Eastern Ladakh which, according to India, is on its side of the Line of Actual Control (LOAC) and set up a temporary camp with tents.

2.Media reports suggest that the Chinese action seems to be in retaliation for India strengthening its military-related infrastructure around the Daulat Beg Oldie area within Indian-claimed LOAC.

3. Three flag meetings at the level of local military commanders have not persuaded the Chinese authorities to vacate the Indian territory occupied by them. The Chinese attitude has been deliberately vague and evasive. It is not even clear whether the Chinese are projecting their vacation as a quid pro quo for India suspending its work on its infrastructure.

4. Ever since Rajiv Gandhi as the Prime Minister visited China in 1988 and had a cordial meeting with Deng Xiao-Ping, the two countries have been following a policy of continuing with the border talks while not allowing the lack of progress in it to affect the development of bilateral relations in the political and economic fields. They have also been following a policy of not taking any action that could affect peace and tranquillity across the LOAC.

5. While de jure adhering to the various confidence-building measures agreed to by  the two countries, the Chinese have de facto been trying to change the ground rules in their favour through a series of steps the implications of which were not initially grasped by India.

6. Firstly, they have avoided for over 20 years exchanging maps indicating the LOAC. As a result, they have sought to make where the LOAC lays a matter of conjecture suiting them than settled fact. Secondly, they went back on the understanding reached between our Prime Minister Dr.Manmohan Singh and their former Prime Minister Mr. Wen Jiabao that any border adjustments in the Arunachal Pradesh area  (Eastern sector) should not affect populated areas. Thirdly, they unilaterally introduced a drastically reduced measurement of the length of the disputed border in the Ladakh sector in a disguised attempt to pave the way for inducting Pakistan as an interested party in the Western sector at a suitable opportunity. And now, fourthly, they have unilaterally sought to change the perceived, but not yet marked LOAC thereby preparing the ground for increasing their sovereignty claims in this area.

7.While  subtly changing the ground situation in their favour and to the detriment of India, they have fully benefitted economically from the agreement not to let the border dispute affect the relations in the political and economic fields. China has become India’s biggest trading partner with a huge surplus trade balance in its favour. The Chinese manufacturing industry has benefited immensely from its ability to export its goods to the Indian market. India has emerged as the largest market for Chinese construction companies which have won more construction contracts in India than in any other country of the world. The relaxed Indian attitude to security considerations have enabled Chinese telecom companies, some of them owned by retired PLA officers, which have been facing difficulties in the West, particularly the US, having a free run of the Indian market. Indian IT companies have not benefitted to the extent expected from their presence in China.

8. Thus, China has been the beneficiary of the policy followed till now. The time has come to revisit this policy and make it clear to China that unless and until the border dispute is settled to mutual satisfaction,  the relations in other fields cannot improve.

9. The Prime Minister should immediately convene a meeting of the National Security Council to discuss a new strategy with the following components and initiate action for their implementation:

Firstly, all exchanges of visits between the leaders of the two countries, and planned joint military exercises should be postponed till China vacates its occupation of Indian territory.

Secondly, India should go ahead with the strengthening of its infrastructure in its territory in all the sectors.

Thirdly, no new construction contracts should be awarded to Chinese companies till the border issue is settled.

Fourthly, no replacement visas should be issued in respect of on-going construction contracts.

10. Our Army should strengthen its presence in the Tawang sector of Arunachal Pradesh to pre-empt the Chinese surprising us there as they have done in Eastern Ladakh. ( 3-5-13)

( The writer is Additional Secretary (retd), Cabinet Secretariat, Govt of India, New Delhi, and, presently, Director, Institute For Topical Studies, Chennai, and Associate of the Chennai Centre Fror China Studies. Twitter @SORBONNE75)


laldo said...

Chinese incursion 19 km inside Indian territory on the LAC,Mr Khurshid intends to go to china.Break all diplomatic relation with china rather than talking & make PLA move back by our armed forces backed by the air-force with supplies & weapons.China,is miffed with India’s re-activation of ALG’s at Daulat Beg Oldi, Fukche and Nyoma and building of other infrastructure along the LAC is baseless as its an internal matter & not in china dikat,moving back by our armed forces will weaken the moral of our armed force due to the cowardness of our failure in the political system

rajeev said...

No pride of being an Indian today.
- Chinese unclothing Indian on LAC
- Beheading of Indian soldiers on LOC
- Murder of Sarabjeet in Pak jail
- multiple Rapes, gang rapes, minor rapes daily in different parts of the country
- unpunished, unsolved terrorist attacks every season in all parts of the country
- Naxalite terrorism
- Endless scandals, corruption and looting by the govt in the last 10 years and your favorite Gandhi dynasty in the last 63 years
- water and electricity shortage
- food inflation
- Money showers and vote buying with Direct deposits
- Tax payer money waste with Nrega
- Human rights violation everywhere in education and govt sector jobs with caste based reservation.

Its an epic shame.

The reason are the poor on whose shoulders such scums (read congress) get elected as leaders to drive and loot the country as they please.

What They don't Want You to Know said...

Don't expect tough measures from a government/party where dynastic loyalty is more important than political ability and leadership. Maybe even the Chinese have realised they need to improve their position ahead of the possible election of Modi next year.

Anshika patel said...


Tent Manufacturers

karthik zinavo said...

Every Indians strongly condemn the action of china for occupy the place in contour of India.They did the same things in many times in our place.I think they do not have sense to make a unwanted things.
Web Designers Bangalore


Dear Beloved Sir,

Today, 18th June 2013, with sorrow,I read about your departure from this world to your heavenly abode. Though I never met you in person, you had exerted some type of influence on me.

May Your Soul Rest At The Divine Feat Of Hanumanji.


web development company said...

Every Indian must read this blog for know the atrocity of china government.
Web Design Company in Bangalore

Coimbatore Web Experts said...

Web design is the effective tool to make more business. Providing the perfect design to show your product will give business.
Website Design Company in Coimbatore | Coimbatore Website Development

siva shankar said...

A good web design company offer web design services at very affordable rate in comparison to any other web design company in the world.
Web Design Companies in Coimbatore | best e-commerce service provider

Logic InfoTech SEO said...

Best SEO Services Affordable Packages and Prices - SEO Experts in coimbatore, chennai Tamil Nadu, India Search engine Optimization Company in india

ICore Software Technologies said...

Are you seeking for professional web designing services? ICore is one of the leading web designing services based at Coimbatore, providing high quality web services with latest online market techniques.
Website Development and Website Designing and seo

Arushi Mathur said...

Download Brothers torrent

Download Brothers utorrent

Brothers torrent download

Jurassic World torrent download

Jupiter Ascending torrent download

Kottai Muthu said...

Best Tourist Place and Packages

Shirdi tour package
Shirdi tour package by Flight from Chennai
Thailand tour packages

Yashika Yamini said...

Its very nice post this is great blog!!
nebosh course in Chennai
Industrial Safety courses
Nebosh safety courses in Chennai
Fire and safety courses

Suseela Susiee said...

All are saying the same thing repeatedly, but in your blog I had a chance to get some useful and unique information, I love your writing style very much, I would like to suggest your blog in my dude circle, so keep on updates.

SEO Company in Chennai

Suseela Susiee said...

What an awesome post, I just read it from start to end. Learned something new after a long time.

SAP FICO Training in Chennai

Kabali Khan said...

safety courses in distance education
safety courses in distance mode
safety courses in distance mode
industrial safety courses in distance
safety distance education
distance safety courses
post graduate diploma in industrial safety distance education
post graduate diploma in industrial safety through distance learning
post graduate diploma in industrial safety health and environment management
post graduate diploma in industrial safety courses
post graduate diploma in industrial safety and environmental management
fire and safety course in distance education
fire and safety course through distance education
safety engineering courses distance learning
distance safety engineering course in india
industrial safety diploma correspondence courses

Safety Professionals said...

good. fire and safety courses in online education

safety 2 said...

nebosh course in Chennai

nebosh courses in Chennai

nebosh in Chennai

safety Professional said...

nebosh course in Chennai
nebosh courses in Chennai
safety course in chennai
nebosh in Chennai
safety courses in chennai

safety 1 said...

nebosh course in Chennai

nebosh courses in Chennai

nebosh in Chennai

safety professionals said...

nebosh course in Chennai
nebosh courses in Chennai
nebosh course in Chennai
nebosh courses in Chennai
nebosh in Chennai
nebosh in Chennai

safety Professional said...

nebosh course in Chennai
nebosh courses in Chennai
safety course in chennai
nebosh courses in Chennai
safety courses in chennai
fire and safety courses in Chennai
nebosh in Chennai
safety courses in Chennai
safety course in chennai

Kavita Reddy said...

I am Kavita Reddy Independent high profile Model Escorts in Mumbai. I am present the natural erotic Escorts Service in Mumbai only for open minded high class authentic gentlemen.
Mumbai Escorts Service
Independent Mumbai Escorts Service
Mumbai Escorts agency
Escorts agency in Mumbai

Philips Huges said...

Nice Sharing..! I have been following you for a couple of months now but this is my first time commenting on a blog post. Thank you for sharing your knowledge and experience with us. Keep up the good work. Already bookmarked for future reference.

Installment loans in Mississippi
Payday loans in Mississippi
Title loans in Mississippi